Pay or Play a Winner in the Bay City

If employers are mandated to provide health insurance,will it be a job killer?  Will it cost American workers income in the form of lost wages?

For the anti-American conservative forces in this country, the answer to this question is a no-brainer – a resounding “Absolutely!”.

For those less ideologically hamstrung, the answer might be “Don’t jump to conclusions”.

The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) released a study recently that concluded conservative fears were without basis.

In the words of the RWJF:

“In contradiction to past research and long-held economic theories, a new study finds that that when facing a “pay-or-play” mandate requiring employers either provide health benefits or contribute to a public option health plan, employers did not lay off staff or cut wages appreciably as a result.”

Novel legislation

The San Francisco law was notable in several ways.  Several states had attempted to legislate some form of an employer mandate.  All were vigorously opposed by anti-American conservatives and business interests who argued – guess – that it would hurt business, cost jobs, and therefore hurt workers.  Those efforts that survived were challenged in court on the grounds that the ERISA preemption clause prevented states from taking this course. Continue reading

San Francisco’s health care a model during debate

by JULIANA BARBASSA

The Associated Press 11/20/09
Friday, November 20, 2009

SAN FRANCISCO — This city did not wait for Washington’s health care overhaul. Most uninsured adults here are already reaping the benefits of a government-run health care program – seeing doctors, filling prescriptions, and getting surgeries they could not otherwise afford.

Healthy San Francisco is the nation’s first city-run universal health care plan. While not insurance and not valid outside the city, it does illustrate how some hotly debated elements of plans being considered on Capitol Hill might play out.

In just over two years, the $126 million program has won over its target population, and now covers about 48,000 people – more than two-thirds of San Franciscans who previously had no insurance.

San Francisco’s health care a model during debate – washingtonpost.com